Part 8 | The Art of Nemawashi: Why Important Decisions Often Happen Before the Meeting

The Strategic Context

Many New Zealand businesses describe Japanese decision-making as slow.

In many cases, that perception is understandable.

Japanese organisations often involve multiple stakeholders, several rounds of discussion and a significant amount of internal consultation before a decision is made.

For businesses accustomed to faster decision-making processes, this can sometimes feel frustrating. Meetings may appear positive, questions may be answered thoroughly and interest may seem genuine, yet a final decision can still take weeks or months to emerge.

However, focusing only on the speed of the decision can obscure a more important point.

The objective is not simply to make a decision quickly. The objective is to ensure the organisation can execute that decision successfully once it is made.

This helps explain the role of Nemawashi (根回し), one of the most important concepts in Japanese business.

The term originally comes from gardening. Before transplanting a tree, gardeners carefully prepare the roots in advance to improve the likelihood that the tree will thrive in its new location.

In business, the principle is remarkably similar.

Nemawashi refers to the informal discussions, consultations and information-sharing that take place before a proposal reaches a formal meeting or approval process.

For many New Zealand businesses, this can be unfamiliar.

In New Zealand, formal meetings are often where questions are raised, concerns are debated and decisions are ultimately made.

In Japan, much of that work may happen before the meeting ever takes place.

Stakeholders may be consulted individually. Questions may be raised and addressed privately. Additional information may be requested. Concerns may be identified and resolved before a proposal is formally presented.

As a result, what appears to be a decision-making meeting may actually be the final step in a much longer process.

Understanding this distinction helps explain why Japanese organisations often spend considerable time building alignment before a formal decision is announced.

Why Nemawashi Matters

From a New Zealand perspective, meetings are often where decisions are made.

In Japan, meetings are frequently where decisions are confirmed.

This distinction can create confusion.

A New Zealand exporter may deliver a strong presentation and leave expecting a rapid answer.

Instead, the response may be:

“We will discuss internally and come back to you.”

This does not necessarily indicate a lack of interest.

More often, it reflects a process designed to reduce organisational risk before commitments are made.

Nemawashi is often the mechanism through which that risk is managed.

Rather than waiting for objections to appear during a formal meeting, Japanese organisations frequently seek to identify concerns in advance.

Rather than forcing stakeholders to debate issues publicly, concerns may be addressed through individual discussions beforehand.

The goal is not to avoid decision-making.

The goal is to improve the likelihood that the eventual decision will be supported and successfully executed.

Three Practical Implications

1. Decisions Often Involve More Stakeholders Than Expected

Many New Zealand businesses assume that the person sitting across the table is the primary decision-maker.

In Japan, that individual may be an important stakeholder, but not necessarily the final decision-maker.

Depending on the organisation, input may be required from multiple departments, managers and executives before a decision can proceed.

Commercial teams, operations teams, technical specialists, procurement functions and senior management may all contribute to the evaluation process.

As a result, securing support from one individual is often only one step in a much larger process.

A proposal may appear successful from the perspective of the meeting itself while still needing to gain support from numerous stakeholders behind the scenes.

2. Comparisons Are Often More Extensive Than Expected

Japanese organisations frequently conduct detailed evaluations before selecting a new supplier, partner or product.

Competing alternatives may be reviewed repeatedly and proposals may be compared against existing suppliers as well as other market options.

In some cases, the strongest competitor is not another supplier at all.

It is the decision to change nothing.

This can be surprising for New Zealand businesses.

A proposal may clearly outperform competing alternatives, yet still face resistance if stakeholders are not convinced that change is necessary.

For this reason, businesses often need more than a good product. They need a compelling reason for an organisation to support change.

This is one reason why differentiation matters so much in Japan. A proposal that is clearly distinct is often easier to evaluate, justify and support internally than one that appears similar to existing alternatives.

3. Consensus Supports Execution

Building consensus takes time.

However, much of that time is spent ensuring that stakeholders understand the proposal, support the decision and are prepared to implement it successfully.

This can make the process appear slow from the outside.

Once agreement is reached, however, implementation often encounters fewer internal obstacles because key stakeholders have already been involved throughout the process.

The goal is not simply to obtain approval.

It is to create organisational alignment before execution begins.

From a Japanese perspective, a decision that cannot be effectively implemented has limited value regardless of how quickly it was made.

The Japan Desk Perspective

At Japan Desk, we often see New Zealand businesses become frustrated by what appears to be slow decision-making.

The challenge is rarely a lack of interest.

More often, it is a reflection of how decisions are evaluated, discussed and supported internally.

What appears to be inactivity from the outside may actually be a period of active consultation, comparison and consensus-building.

Understanding where a proposal sits within that process can be just as important as the proposal itself.

Our role is to help businesses navigate these discussions, identify key stakeholders and maintain momentum while internal evaluations take place.

Successful outcomes in Japan often depend not only on the quality of the offering, but also on understanding how decisions are made.

The Bottom Line

Japanese decision-making can take longer than many New Zealand businesses expect.

This is often not because organisations are unwilling to decide, but because they are investing time in building support before a decision is made.

Nemawashi is not about avoiding decisions.

It is about reducing risk, building alignment and improving the likelihood of successful execution.

Businesses that understand this process are often better positioned to build support, reduce friction and navigate complex organisations more effectively.

The objective is not simply to win the meeting. It is to build alignment before the meeting takes place.


In Part 9, we explore why Japanese clients often remain loyal for many years and how trust accumulates through consistent execution over time.

Read Part 9

If you’re evaluating opportunities in Japan, we are available to discuss the practical considerations involved.

Continue Exploring the Series

This article is part of The NZ Leader’s Strategic Guide to Japan, a 10-part series examining the practical realities of building successful business relationships in Japan.

Explore the other articles in the series:

PART

Learn why many successful businesses treat Japan as a distinct market rather than simply another part of a broader Asia strategy.

PART

Explore how working with Japanese partners can strengthen operational discipline, execution capability and commercial credibility.

PART

Understand why supply chain reliability and freshness expectations can influence commercial success beyond simple compliance.

PART

Discover how continuous improvement helps build trust, strengthen partnerships and support long-term success in Japan.

Part

Learn why Japanese partners often value predictability over silence, and how regular updates help reduce uncertainty and build confidence.

PART

Discover how New Zealand businesses can stand out by making it easier for Japanese buyers to understand, justify and support a purchasing decision.

PART

Learn how packaging, presentation and attention to detail influence buyer confidence long before a product is ever used.

PART
Current ArticleThe Art of Nemawashi: Why Important Decisions Often Happen Before the Meeting

PART

Learn how consistent execution, reliability and relationship capital contribute to long-term business relationships in Japan.

PART

Discover why understanding Japan is only the beginning, and why long-term success depends on consistent execution, communication and relationship management.


In this Insights